Subject: Re: "Wall-E" Andrew Stanton has ripped off "Short Circuit"
Author: The Starmaker
Date: 5 Jul
Ref:

Disneygeek wrote:
>
> On Jul 4, 1:41 am, The Starmaker <starma...@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
> > Disneygeek wrote:
> >
> > > On Jul 3, 12:51 pm, The Starmaker <starma...@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
> > > > Now, for my professional opinion...
> > > > consider me an expert witness.
> >
> > > > As a professional artist
> > > > knowing about the
> > > > world of art...
> >
> > > > It's *impossible*
> > > > for Andrew Stanton
> > > > to come up with the
> > > > design of Wall-e
> > > > without the aid of
> > > > either the actual
> > > > "Short Circuit" robot
> > > > Johnny-5 in his presence,
> > > > or having numerous photos
> > > > of "Johnny-5" at every angle including
> > > > the back of the robot.
> >
> > > > It's *IMPOSSIBLE*
> > > > for Andrew Stanton
> > > > to design Wall-e
> > > > from memory. He had to
> > > > have had the photographs
> > > > to use as reference while
> > > > the drawing and designing
> > > > of Wall-e.
> >
> > > > Johnny-5 is the father
> > > > of Wall-e. They both have the
> > > > same last name, "5", the fifth
> > > > letter of the alphabet is "E".
> >
> > > > Johnny is the father and Wally is his son.
> >
> > > > Wall-e is a baby version of Johnny-e.
> >
> > > > I don't want to hear any more discussion about this!
> > > > The guy is a fuckin thief and he knows it!!
> >
> > > No, you strike me as the kind who doesn't want to discuss anything
> > > with people who disagree with you.
> >
> > Well, who in the world wants to have a discussion with people who
> > disagree?
> > You disagree, FINE..I'm not going to discuss it with you!
>
> Of course, the whole point of open frank discussion is to discuss your
> points of view with people who have differeing points of view. But you
> wouldn't follow that.

I'm not here to have "frank discussions". I'm here to inform, educate,
announce, broadcast...
otherwise why would I post to a million newsgroups at once?

If I felt I wanted to have a discussion, I would post to only one
newsgroup at a time.

>
> > There are none so blind as those, that will not see.
> > The Starmaker
>
> And you are one of the five blind men who perceived the elephant as a
> snake.
>
> > I cannot believe for a moment you're a disneygeek. You of all people
> > should
> > know what original design is all about.
>
> Now this really makes no sense. I can't be a "disneygeek" because I
> won't take your side trashing Disney over what is, at best, a minor
> design point?

I don't want you to take my side...


"Wall-E" Andrew Stanton has ripped off "Short Cir…
4 JulDisneygeek
4 Jul\ The Starmaker
4 Jul   \ Disneygeek
4 Jul      |- The Starmaker
5 Jul      \ The Starmaker